Generalist vs Specialist: Which One Suits You Best as a Talent?

^{image source: Vecteezy}

“Jack of all trades, master of none.” Have you ever heard of this figure of speech? It refers to an individual who has dabbled in many skills but hasn’t gained any expertise in any of them. Do you fall into this type of talent?

At some point along your career journey, you probably wonder whether you want to become a specialist in a particular field or to pursue the path of a generalist. Although these specific conditions vary by industry, both refer to how extensive or specific your expertise is, whether in a limited scope or across a diverse set of skills. Either is better than the other, as each type serves different purposes and is needed for different roles. Here’s more what you need to know about generalist vs specialist to determine which one suits you best as a talent.

Definition of Generalist vs Specialist

In terms of roles, generalists typically have responsibilities that are rather loosely defined inside companies. If specialists are subject matter experts, generalists are seen as jacks of all trades. Though they may not study as deeply into areas as specialists, a generalist's strength lies in their understanding of all the parts of a business. As their knowledge base includes a much broader spectrum, generalists are generally excellent mediators between departments. One close example of generalists is homeroom teachers in an elementary school, where they typically teach many subjects to the students.

On the other hand, specialists indulge in one specific position for a particular profession, sector, or market; their expertise is limited but extensive. Specialists thrive in businesses that engage them to be their go-to people for a new process, policy, or technological advancement. New updates in any business might be difficult for common people to understand without the comprehensive understanding of a specialist. This is why specialists frequently come from backgrounds with vast experience doing only one thing. For example, a company may hire a Search Engine Optimization (SEO) specialist to ensure its marketing strategy stays current, as the Internet and algorithms are ever-changing.

Advantages of Being a Generalist

Being a generalist can be both beneficial and challenging. Individuals with a broad range of knowledge can identify the connections across departments and find ways to benefit their entire team or department. Moreover, generalists are less prone to feeling bored doing mundane tasks. Another significant advantage of being a generalist is career flexibility since they have a multitude of transferable skills at their disposal. This makes it easier for them to pursue a wider range of job possibilities. It is no surprise that generalists are more likely to be leaders and managers within businesses since they possess a wide range of transferable skills. If they understand how to handle employees, they will be able to do so for wider choices of industry. 

Read Also: Simple Ways to Create a Powerful Internal Presentation

Advantages of being a Specialist

Choosing to become a specialist can offer a range of exciting opportunities and challenges. When there are fewer people who specialize in a certain field, there are fewer rivals in the jobs market. Specialists' salaries may also be bigger due to their higher education and qualifications. They have acquired knowledge in their specific field, which is difficult to come by, and so the position of a specialist can be important to a company. The company frequently includes a few specialists working in several fields, which means that the entire company will rely on their skills. This not only increases the prospects of a greater salary but also gives the specialist a stronger position when it comes to negotiating employment terms.

Disadvantages of Being a Generalist

Since generalists are not experts in a single topic or expertise, it can be difficult for them to demonstrate their value within a company, particularly one that is highly complex. However, if they can promote themselves by proving the value of having different abilities and knowledge, they will hold an important position in the company. Moreover, as their talents are not as unique, replacing a generalist may be easier than finding a new specialist. This means they can have less job security compared to specialists. 

Disadvantages of Being a Specialist

Individuals who concentrate in one profession face a risk of being substituted by other methods, such as technology, and having to choose a new career path. Consequently, the accessible career prospects are limited in contrast to generalists. As specialists have highly specialized skills and expertise, it may be difficult for them to find available positions or jobs outside of their primary sector. However, once they find a job, they may stay in it for several years, sometimes even for their whole life. Another way to deal with this is preparing specialists to expand their knowledge that is more marketable and in demand, even if it means dedicating time to learn new things.

Which One is Better for the Job Market?

If your talents are specialized, you may be better suited in a position at a bigger company where your expertise will stand out from your peers who can do broader duties within that industry. Depending on what you perform, you can also be recruited in smaller businesses for specific positions. For generalists, a job at a startup with your vast knowledge can be beneficial for its survival, since your skill set fits the fast flexibility required for the company's success. Moreover, as generalists tend to be better at interacting, across divisions, you can also assume more managerial positions in larger companies.

As both experts and generalists are necessary for a company's success, there is no definitive answer as to which is superior. Recognizing your ability and true potential is the first step toward determining where you fit best. Be it as a generalist or a specialist, Talentvis is ready to help you find your dream job that best fits your skill!

Read Also: Job Search Tips: How to Build a Better LinkedIn Profile